"By ordering Aquino’s assassination, Marcos had miscalculated—badly. True, he had rid himself of his longtime nemesis and primary electoral threat. But far from shoring up his regime, he had set in motion forces that would lead to its collapse."
Now contrast this to the tiny whimper of discontent when Putin murdered Navalny, and it becomes obvious that the modern dictatorship (at least in Russia, China, Iran etc) is built on far sturdier stuff. If the common people hardly give a fig the dictatorship can survive a lot, but even if they mostly all hate the regime, as long as the troops stay loyal they can still survive.
Yes, I agree that mounting a viable challenge to dictatorships in Russia and China, especially, would be far more difficult. But most authoritarian regimes today are not nearly as stifling; they're what we call "competitive authoritarian" systems. There's an above-ground opposition. There are elections which, while not fair, are free enough that the opposition can win. People can organize, protest, etc.
By that I suppose you mean Hungary? In Turkey, the winner of the Istanbul major election was just imprisoned. I don't know if there are really that many regimes where the opposition stands a chance.
Not really true. Authoritarian incumbents have recently lost elections in (1) Senegal (2024), Brazil (2022), Poland (2023), Guatemala (2023), Zambia (2021), and Liberia (2023).
Yes, but they were really weak compared to Turkey, Iran, Russia etc. Any wannabe autocrat worth his salt will make sure there is not a chance for the opposition to ever gain any real power. We will see where the United States is at the end of 2028, but given that Bolsonaro was given his just desserts by Brazil's supreme court and Trump was not, I think the US will have the harder time by comparison in getting out of this mess.
"By ordering Aquino’s assassination, Marcos had miscalculated—badly. True, he had rid himself of his longtime nemesis and primary electoral threat. But far from shoring up his regime, he had set in motion forces that would lead to its collapse."
Now contrast this to the tiny whimper of discontent when Putin murdered Navalny, and it becomes obvious that the modern dictatorship (at least in Russia, China, Iran etc) is built on far sturdier stuff. If the common people hardly give a fig the dictatorship can survive a lot, but even if they mostly all hate the regime, as long as the troops stay loyal they can still survive.
Yes, I agree that mounting a viable challenge to dictatorships in Russia and China, especially, would be far more difficult. But most authoritarian regimes today are not nearly as stifling; they're what we call "competitive authoritarian" systems. There's an above-ground opposition. There are elections which, while not fair, are free enough that the opposition can win. People can organize, protest, etc.
By that I suppose you mean Hungary? In Turkey, the winner of the Istanbul major election was just imprisoned. I don't know if there are really that many regimes where the opposition stands a chance.
Not really true. Authoritarian incumbents have recently lost elections in (1) Senegal (2024), Brazil (2022), Poland (2023), Guatemala (2023), Zambia (2021), and Liberia (2023).
Yes, but they were really weak compared to Turkey, Iran, Russia etc. Any wannabe autocrat worth his salt will make sure there is not a chance for the opposition to ever gain any real power. We will see where the United States is at the end of 2028, but given that Bolsonaro was given his just desserts by Brazil's supreme court and Trump was not, I think the US will have the harder time by comparison in getting out of this mess.