Excellent; well said. And then, of course, there is the minor issue of taking Putin at face value in terms of any assurances he may offer or agreements he might sign. For a bunch of realists, they seem awfully naive in their belief that an agreement would be enduring. I seem to recall something that was signed in Budapest a while back....
Not to mention, none of these clowns seem to acknowledge Russia’s stated aims, which is a lot more than the currently occupied territories. Why would anyone try to ”make a deal” with someone who explicitly says they’re gonna be back for more?
Your feet-firmly-on-the-ground realism is such a welcome and needed rebuttal of the feet-deeply-lodged-in-mouth inanities peddled by the Putler pundits. Anyone arguing that we should ‘take account of the Kremlin’s legitimate security interests’ should be made to write out the text of the 1994 Budapest Memorandum 100 times and then be required by law to begin any article by quoting it in full.
Another issue these experts seem to either ignore, or be unaware of, is that Russian negotiations are always underlaid by a win-lose mentality. Bringing that mediation approach of negotiating each side’s interests will not work with Russia because that would always be interpreted as “We lost”.
I can't describe how it feels for us here in Ukraine to read some of your esteemed colleagues. I thought this war would finally help them to understand that Ukrainians, surprisingly, have some agency, and, I know it might sound wild, might know thing or two Ukr-Rus relationships too. Hell, we might even have something interesting to say about it if one is willing to listen, but I guess that's a bridge too far for many of them.
Would be great to also dismantle Prof. Kotkin crazy ideas of letting China to manage the piece talks in his latest lecture, as well as the latest piece in Foreign Affairs by Samuel Charap.
Another issue worth noting is that Russia has annexed Kherson and Zaporizhzhia, and insists that as part of any peace talks Ukraine must "recognize the new territorial realities". This is what in my opinion makes peace talks impossible as long as Putin remains in power - you simply cannot negotiate if your opponent claims that you must recognize that they have permanently seized 20% of your territory. Until the "referendum" took place it could in theory have been possible to negotiate an end to the war, but this option is gone now.
Years later, your text still stands as clear, clean and near prophetic. Congrats, congrats!!!
Yes, the names that you identify just have some inner urge to suck out all the oxygen out of the Ukrainians in any room they are even close to. What the hell do some far away Ukrainians know about the love affair the Western academics have with Kremlin Muscovy Ethnics.
The term WESTSPLAINERS is used to identify academics + others who just totally know how that misunderstood Kremlin Muscovy Ethnic tribe is just not perceived by us lesser mortals. They must be the one op-ed voice that can explain all to us morons.
Then there is the University of Chicago tax paid tenured Oxygen sucker. Now, he has pod casts and a media appearance schedule that would make one think he knew something about Ukraine.
So Professor J.J. Mearsheimer travels to Moscow, meets the highest ranking international war criminals at dinner, etc., and claims he only saw "NORMAL" humans in normal society while cavorting about Moscow.
Read + listen to his incessant Kremlin narratives about Ukraine. There seems to be no season in no year in which JJM has not predicted that Ukraine must fall down and surrender to the Muscovy.
This well paid tenured Oxygen thief just refuses to take on any "guest" who may puncture or slightly challenge his overwhelming love and affection for ole Mother Land Ruuzzkie.
While an expert on the NAZI army, Professor JJM just stays so strangely silent on how that state of POLAND vanished in 1939 and who exactly took all those many thousands of POLISH Intellectual leaders for a train ride to the Genocide pits of Katyn. Professor JJM just never wishes to reveal the forever fervent genetic need of fascist Motherland Muscovy to be cuddled + bedded + married to NAZI Fatherland Hitler!
The problem is that the academic signers and Professors of the air waves can never be seen as demanding to interview and do multiple re-calls with N.A. Abrams.
Why do they all avoid any contact with N.A Abrams?
They all can be identified by their call sign: their Quisling quietness call. They all refuse to demand the stop of the war with their personal use of one simple sentence. They all refuse, categorically, to state clearly, loudly: "Putin, immediately instruct all your Kremlin Muscovy Troops ( + foreigners ) to withdraw to the 2013 border lines while leaving gold bullion in the amount of one Billion USD for the first payment of the needed compensation, reparation and rehabilitation of maimed, raped, displaced, tortured, mass abducted, mass trafficked Ukrainians.
Once the millions of international war criminal Muscovy hear that call they realize that their gamble to steal 75 trillion of Ukrainian resources is revealed, over + they must flee, get out before they are seized for appearance in trial before an International criminal court!
Suddenly the Crimean Bridge will be flooded with criminals in silent prayer that their gas does not run out while they are still on top of the bridge, not clear + safe in hometown Moscow.
Do keep your op-ed on these academics current!! Thank you, again!!
“... torture, enforced disappearance, summary execution, hostage-taking, illegal detention, falsification of criminal cases, arson, and a lack of fair trials ...”, ah, Israel, i get it
Excellent; well said. And then, of course, there is the minor issue of taking Putin at face value in terms of any assurances he may offer or agreements he might sign. For a bunch of realists, they seem awfully naive in their belief that an agreement would be enduring. I seem to recall something that was signed in Budapest a while back....
Exactly. I was going to bring that up but didn’t want to make the post too long.
Not to mention, none of these clowns seem to acknowledge Russia’s stated aims, which is a lot more than the currently occupied territories. Why would anyone try to ”make a deal” with someone who explicitly says they’re gonna be back for more?
Your feet-firmly-on-the-ground realism is such a welcome and needed rebuttal of the feet-deeply-lodged-in-mouth inanities peddled by the Putler pundits. Anyone arguing that we should ‘take account of the Kremlin’s legitimate security interests’ should be made to write out the text of the 1994 Budapest Memorandum 100 times and then be required by law to begin any article by quoting it in full.
Another issue these experts seem to either ignore, or be unaware of, is that Russian negotiations are always underlaid by a win-lose mentality. Bringing that mediation approach of negotiating each side’s interests will not work with Russia because that would always be interpreted as “We lost”.
I agree.
Thank you, Mr. Abrams.
I can't describe how it feels for us here in Ukraine to read some of your esteemed colleagues. I thought this war would finally help them to understand that Ukrainians, surprisingly, have some agency, and, I know it might sound wild, might know thing or two Ukr-Rus relationships too. Hell, we might even have something interesting to say about it if one is willing to listen, but I guess that's a bridge too far for many of them.
Замечательно, отлично. С чувством, с толком, с расстановкой. Спасибо.
Спасибо Вам, Валерий!
Would be great to also dismantle Prof. Kotkin crazy ideas of letting China to manage the piece talks in his latest lecture, as well as the latest piece in Foreign Affairs by Samuel Charap.
Thank you for this article!
Another issue worth noting is that Russia has annexed Kherson and Zaporizhzhia, and insists that as part of any peace talks Ukraine must "recognize the new territorial realities". This is what in my opinion makes peace talks impossible as long as Putin remains in power - you simply cannot negotiate if your opponent claims that you must recognize that they have permanently seized 20% of your territory. Until the "referendum" took place it could in theory have been possible to negotiate an end to the war, but this option is gone now.
Years later, your text still stands as clear, clean and near prophetic. Congrats, congrats!!!
Yes, the names that you identify just have some inner urge to suck out all the oxygen out of the Ukrainians in any room they are even close to. What the hell do some far away Ukrainians know about the love affair the Western academics have with Kremlin Muscovy Ethnics.
The term WESTSPLAINERS is used to identify academics + others who just totally know how that misunderstood Kremlin Muscovy Ethnic tribe is just not perceived by us lesser mortals. They must be the one op-ed voice that can explain all to us morons.
Then there is the University of Chicago tax paid tenured Oxygen sucker. Now, he has pod casts and a media appearance schedule that would make one think he knew something about Ukraine.
So Professor J.J. Mearsheimer travels to Moscow, meets the highest ranking international war criminals at dinner, etc., and claims he only saw "NORMAL" humans in normal society while cavorting about Moscow.
Read + listen to his incessant Kremlin narratives about Ukraine. There seems to be no season in no year in which JJM has not predicted that Ukraine must fall down and surrender to the Muscovy.
This well paid tenured Oxygen thief just refuses to take on any "guest" who may puncture or slightly challenge his overwhelming love and affection for ole Mother Land Ruuzzkie.
While an expert on the NAZI army, Professor JJM just stays so strangely silent on how that state of POLAND vanished in 1939 and who exactly took all those many thousands of POLISH Intellectual leaders for a train ride to the Genocide pits of Katyn. Professor JJM just never wishes to reveal the forever fervent genetic need of fascist Motherland Muscovy to be cuddled + bedded + married to NAZI Fatherland Hitler!
The problem is that the academic signers and Professors of the air waves can never be seen as demanding to interview and do multiple re-calls with N.A. Abrams.
Why do they all avoid any contact with N.A Abrams?
They all can be identified by their call sign: their Quisling quietness call. They all refuse to demand the stop of the war with their personal use of one simple sentence. They all refuse, categorically, to state clearly, loudly: "Putin, immediately instruct all your Kremlin Muscovy Troops ( + foreigners ) to withdraw to the 2013 border lines while leaving gold bullion in the amount of one Billion USD for the first payment of the needed compensation, reparation and rehabilitation of maimed, raped, displaced, tortured, mass abducted, mass trafficked Ukrainians.
Once the millions of international war criminal Muscovy hear that call they realize that their gamble to steal 75 trillion of Ukrainian resources is revealed, over + they must flee, get out before they are seized for appearance in trial before an International criminal court!
Suddenly the Crimean Bridge will be flooded with criminals in silent prayer that their gas does not run out while they are still on top of the bridge, not clear + safe in hometown Moscow.
Do keep your op-ed on these academics current!! Thank you, again!!
“... torture, enforced disappearance, summary execution, hostage-taking, illegal detention, falsification of criminal cases, arson, and a lack of fair trials ...”, ah, Israel, i get it
Yeah? Which is also bad. What point do you think you're making here?
Ukraine is only the small beginning.
This time we (even non-Russians) will not be communists but only Partisans, and denazify the whole world, first NATO, forever and ever.
Ukraine is only the small beginning.
This time we (even non-Russians) will not be communists but only Partisans, and denazify the whole world, first NATO, forever and ever.